Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Geary Johansen's avatar

It's a good critique of conservatism, But what's the alternative? Trump populism (or Milei libertarianism) might address the economic layer, but it doesn't really address the cultural layer- other than in rolling back DEI. This won't work. Most educators will simply refuse to teach young people just how many times Socialism has been tried, or that it's failed abysmally every single time.

It's a broader problem with Revolutions- revolutions only work when they are movements peopled by those fighting for rights, access to opportunity and cultural inheritances already possessed by other people!

I also think any of the more drastic solutions will work. Community and human connectedness is a good start, because it addresses the central problem of power accumulation at the top of any political system, with its innate tendency to dehumanise, but there is no romance to such observations. Heroic struggle is a bad formula as well- it has a history of coalescing into Counter Enlightenment movements. The best I can up with is a form of creative realism- a movement which places truth and beauty above hurty feelings. Sure, this is a form of heroic struggle, but at least it's a productive one.

The problem is you need a movement which incorporates a sense of moral mission, without alienating people. The Left does this by resorting to what Shelby Steele calls Poetic Truths- beliefs which sound right, but prove wrong when examined. Will the Right resort to the same tactics? To win by lying seems like the same means versus ends justifications the Left is fond of deploying...

Thoughts?

Expand full comment
An American Writer & Essayist's avatar

Good article. Conservative is only functional when they are conserving a morally upright society. Hey, what do you think of Thomas Sankara?

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?